The First Impression Advantage: Mastering the First Glimpse for Powerful Modern Leadership

Expert commentary by Nina Fountain, The Executive Stylist. Supported by AI. Improved and fact-checked by Nina to ensure accuracy and readability. Includes original content.

© Copyright Style Gorgeous 2025.

In our fast-moving world, leaders have precisely 100 milliseconds to establish trust before their audience forms lasting judgments. This isn't hyperbole—it's robust neuroscience. As a result, the three non-negotiable elements of modern leadership presence are instant credibility, authority that adapts to context and strategic styling for high-stakes moments.

According to Nina Fountain, The Executive Stylist: "Purpose-led Presence™️ transforms how leaders show up in milliseconds, not months." The compound effect of strategic visual messaging creates measurable career acceleration.

The One-Tenth Second Rule: Why First Impressions Are Everything

Researchers agree that first impressions powerfully influence trust, including in leadership settings. This insight reveals that our brains process visual information before conscious thought begins at between 150 milliseconds and 350 milliseconds.

The one-tenth second rule operates on three distinct levels:

Credibility Assessment

Our neural pathways evaluate competence through posture, colour choices, and facial expressions - sometimes within milliseconds. Body posture can influence judgments of competence and confidence—e.g., "power poses" and confident body language. Colour can influence attractiveness and perceived dominance. Facial cues are used to rapidly assess competence, trustworthiness and likability.

Warmth Calibration

Micro-expressions and colour temperatures communicate approachability instantly. Micro-expressions are brief, involuntary facial expressions that reveal true emotions, typically lasting between 1/25 to 1/5 of a second. Depending on the context, colour can also communicate approachability - for example some people may find that warm undertones or bright colours signal approachability.

Competence Signalling

Visual cues such as structured clothing and carefully chosen accessories reliably influence first impressions of expertise and professionalism - again, before any conversation begins. For example clothing with structured shapes (e.g., blazers, tailored fits, sharp lines) is often associated with professionalism, authority, and expertise. Accessories (like watches, eyeglasses, briefcases, pens, etc.) can reinforce an impression of expertise, if they are perceived as intentional and relevant to the context. The brain categorises leadership capability through these instant visual assessments.

As Maya Angelou observed, "People will forget what you said, people will forget what you did, but people will never forget how you made them feel." It's incredible to think that this emotional imprint happens faster than conscious awareness.

Adapting Executive Presence for Hybrid Environments

With much of our leadership occurring online, modern leaders need to make a great digital first impression. This goes beyond the traditional sense of leadership presence, which was established mainly by attire and voice or speaking style. If you're a modern leader today there is a need to recalibrate your appearance to the presence you want to carry in online settings. The four pillars of thios hybrid leadership presence are lighting mastery, camera positioning, background curation, and wardrobe translation. 

Lighting Mastery

Lighting influences cognitive and emotional responses, shaping how people interpret and react to others visually. The intensity, direction, color, and contrast of light can affect mood, attention, and how traits like competence are perceived. While no studies explicitly isolate "lighting angle" as a sole factor for perceived competence, lighting direction affects shadows and highlights on a face or figure, which in turn influence impressions of authority, professionalism, and competence by altering visual cues such as clarity and facial prominence. Expert commentary from Nina Fountain is as follows: "As incredible as it may sound, being well-lit by lighting at the right angles can enhance our perceived professionalism and authority by shaping our most salient visual features."

Camera positioning

The position of your camera affects how you are seen as a leader. A 2023 study with a large sample (N=2,474) found that the camera angle along the vertical axis strongly shapes how leaders are perceived. When leaders are viewed from above (a high camera angle), they are seen as less charismatic, less prototypical of their leadership role, and receive lower approval ratings compared to an eye-level perspective.

Effects of low angle shots (looking up at the leader) were less clear but generally, steep angles from either above or below reduced approval. Isn't that powerful?! The best camera angle is eye-to-eye with the viewer. Leaders who make eye contact with the camera and are viewed at eye-level tend to receive higher ratings of trustworthiness, charisma, and approval.

Background curation

There is growing research indicating that in digital or virtual settings, leadership relationships and components such as influence, trust, motivation, and rapport can be affected by their digital background. Although direct experimental studies are limited, research on modern leadership shows that context and environment (which would include video call backgrounds) contribute to signaling professionalism, openness, and psychological safety. This means our video background is another signal that helps build influence and trust even before verbal communication begins.

Wardrobe translation

Wardrobe and attire are powerful tools for leaders to enhance their influence, trustworthiness, motivation, and rapport within their teams and organizations. The effect of leaders' attire is well-documented. Attire is well known to affect a leader's ability to inspire influence, trust, motivation, and rapport. Dressing in a way that mirrors the visual standards of current leadership boosts perceptions of trust and credibility, reinforcing the idea that the individual fits and belongs at a higher level of responsibility. Research into enclothed cognition demonstrates that what leaders wear doesn’t just impact how others see them but also directly influences their self-confidence, cognitive performance, and executive presence.

Strategic Styling for High-Visibility Moments

Styling that makes an impact in high stakes moments has three key features. Each feature builds on the other, to support leaders to carry their most credible, powerful presence.

Attunement to your audience

Television interviews have different considerations to podcast recordings, which are different to website and branding photography, which are different again to keynote speaking and to leading a team. In each of these situations, Purpose-led Presence™️ comes from firstly being aware of your audience and dressing to support your goal. Each audience has different values, and when you dress in attunement with those values you show "I get how things work around here". You're more likely to be seen by your audience as "one of us", which means you're more likely to be both seen and heard. For example, a keynote speaker in tech would dress very differently to a speaker for a Management Consulting crowd. Missing this attunement step puts a barrier in the way of easy influence, trust and credibility.

Authenticity to your personality

Once you're dressing in line with the values of your audience, the next step in Purpose-led Presence™️ is to connect with your authentic personality. You want to then use your attire to convey your personality non-verbally - before you open your mouth, matching your visual language with your verbal language. Your core personality traits are conveyed in what you wear. Nina Fountain's industry experience has shown that four core traits are evident, in line with the widely researched Big Five model of personality: openness, conscientiousness, agreeablness and extraversion. Dressing in alignment with your personality traits makes it easy for people to understand you. For example, if you dress as someone highy conscientious, in a monochrome black structured suit, but you're really very open minded and creative, people could be confused and fail to build an easy rapport. They would also fail to realise your creativity and true strengths.

It's never good to compromise attunement here - that's when you've gone so far into 'authenticity' that you could compromise your purpose. If you're there to lead and serve, attunement is always the first and most important piece.

Authority through alignment with your role

Lastly, your high-stakes styling moments require you to consistently turn up in the same way if you want Purpose-led Presence™️ - consistent with your purpose and your role. Your purpose is conveyed by dressing in line with your expected role. People have many subtle associations with various roles - for example if you imagine an executive leader, a lawyer and a librarian, they are probably each in different attire. For this reason, your attire gives a strong visual cue about how you see your role in the situation. It's when you're the executive leader who sometimes looks like the barista that people can be confused. Of course, if the situation is a café, that's another story. Another classic example is that a leader will dress differently on an off-site to how they dress to present to the board. The bottom line is: don't give people a reason to question the narrative you're conveying through your attire - that you're both warm and competent - trustworthy.

The Career Acceleration Effect

There is valid scientific research supporting the idea that attire influences professional perceptions, performance, and self-esteem. It's not hard to see how each of these can lead to career acceleration - the person who is more confident in their abilities, able to perform and well socially connected will attract opportunities more easily.

Improved productivity

The same studies from Temple University also found that employees report improved work performance when they dress in a way that’s both authentic and appropriate for their workplace.

Similarly, 'Enclothed cognition' is a validated psychological concept: clothing not only affects how others see us, but also how we perform. Wearing attire perceived as "work-related" primes people mentally for their professional roles. This priming also increases feelings of power and capability.

Self-perception and networking

Attire impacts self-perception and productivity. Studies from Temple University found that employees feel more confident when they dress in a way that’s both authentic and appropriate for their workplace. Dressing well also encourages more social interactions with colleagues, which may lead to broader networking benefits.

Visual consistency and appropriate dress help establish credibility and can make professionals appear more authoritative, trustworthy, and approachable. This, in turn, can improve first impressions, networking opportunities, and confidence when engaging with peers and potential clients.

Status points

High-status, tailored, or consistent attire may lead others to view someone as holding a higher position or possessing more authority within their organization.

In summary, numerous validated studies indicate that managing attire and visual consistency does benefit career outcomes—particularly via self-confidence, perceptions of authority, networking, and productivity.

Future Implications: The Evolution of Visual Authority

Two emerging technology trends have the potential to reshape executive presence: AI-powered style analysis and virtual and Virtual Reality (VR) meetings. Leaders at the bleeding edge are already adapting to these technological shifts.

AI-powered style analysis

AI has the capacity to help leaders with both their visual language and their verbal language styles.

Regarding personal style - AI is improving in its ability to analyse colours, although Nina Fountain's expert commentary confirms that AI tools are not fully accurate: "While most of my clients are trying AI alongside my hyperprecise colour analysis, their AI tools are still not accurate and are sending them in the wrong direction." AI tools can be useful for suggesting similar pieces, refining recommendations based on trends and measuring body shape accurately. These become powerful tools in the context of Purpose-led Presence™️, enabling a woman of influence to spend less time on the practical side of working with her wardrobe.

With regard to communication, AI can provide pointers on presentation style, confidence, and overall executive presence. Platforms now use video analytics, natural language processing, and behavioral metrics to track and improve micro-behaviors (gesture, eye contact, voice modulation, strategic pauses), democratising access to executive coaching and leadership development. The trend is not theoretical—these tools exist and are used for measurable improvement in executive presence and perceived leadership capability.

Virtual and Virtual Reality Presence

Numerous executive coaches and industry analysts cite the rise of remote work and virtual meetings as transforming influences, which are changing how leaders project authority, build trust, and inspire action. Executive presence in virtual spaces has become a critical skill, demanding intentional communication, technical proficiency, and strategies for audience engagement. The ability to radiate gravitas and charisma over digital platforms, including Virtual Reality, is now a valuable skill in hybrid and remote environments.

Richard Branson captured this evolution perfectly: "Every success story is a tale of constant adaption, revision and change. A company that stands still will soon be forgotten."

The Millisecond Imperative

Leadership success coexists with mastering the first glimpse. The science is clear: leaders have just 100 milliseconds to establish credibility before lasting judgments form. This isn't about vanity—it's about strategic influence.

Modern leadership presence requires instant credibility, contextual authority and consistent visual authority. When leaders align their visual messaging with their audience's values, authentic personality, and professional role, they create Purpose-led Presence™️ that transforms both perception and performance.

Leaders who master their presence through their attire report improved productivity, enhanced networking, and increased confidence—compound benefits that distinguish exceptional leaders from the merely competent.

For leaders who want to succeed, mastering the first glimpse isn't optional.